Mr. Coffee Under-Extraction / Short Brew Time

Coffee tastes weak or watery even when using normal amounts of coffee.

Advertisements

Possible Causes

Water passing too quickly through grounds, Incorrect grind size (too coarse), Malfunctioning showerhead spray pattern, Incorrect brew strength setting

How to Fix / Troubleshooting

Safety first: No internal repair is required for taste issues.

  • Adjust coffee and grind:
    • Use a medium grind suitable for drip coffee.
    • Increase coffee dose slightly (e.g., 1–2 extra tablespoons per full pot).
  • Use strong brew setting:
    • If your Mr. Coffee has a STRONG or BOLD setting, enable it to slow the brew.
  • Clean showerhead:
    • Remove the brew basket and inspect the water outlet holes above it.
    • Clean any clogged holes with a toothpick and wipe with a damp cloth.

If water is streaming from only one or two holes, the showerhead plate may be damaged and require replacement.

Advertisements

Repair Difficulty

Very Easy 1/5

Required Part

Showerhead Plate
Check Price on Amazon

We may earn a commission from links on this page.

Advertisements